Defense Committee Hearing
| |
Bernard_Oriel | Date: Tuesday, 19 Jun 2012, 9:29 AM | Message # 1 |
Colonel general
Group: Users
Messages: 803
Status: Offline
| After all the correct members and interested parties arrived, Oriel banged the gavel as the ushers called for silence.
"The Planetary Defense Committee of the Imperial Senate is called to order.
Today we are convened to discuss the application from Senator Stark to have his company granted an Aurek-class License for the production of autonomous weaponized "drones".
First and foremost, I would like to call upon Senator Stark for a statement and details of the endorsements he has received as required under the Act. I will then open the floor for the committee to make any statements they wish to make and call any expert witnesses they wish that should be brought to the attention of the Committee. Mr Stark is also welcome to call witnesses in support of his application after this stage has been completed."
He clicked on Stark's microphone "Away you go Senator, in your own time."
Bernard Oriel Senator for the Planet of Vjun 1st Earl Malreaux (Second Creation) Vjun Delegation to the Imperial Senate
|
|
| |
Alyn_Stark | Date: Tuesday, 19 Jun 2012, 12:20 PM | Message # 2 |
Generalissimo
Group: Users
Messages: 1359
Status: Offline
| Stark was appearing via HoloNet in this case, being off-world at the moment and on Lorrd.
"Thank you, Senator Oriel. I would begin by stating, as you have asked, that my endorsements come from Governor Tu'Rot of Acherin, Senator Thanatos of Chandrila, Senator Domon of Sluis Van and, prior to his injuries, Representative Lekpin of Lorrd. The drones in question that are applicable under the current rendition of this license are as follows: the Kill-shot Rapid Reconnaissance series one drone; the Airstrike series three drone and the Interceptor series two drone."
Alyn Stark Lord of Kinyov Senior Captain, Retired, Republic Navy Head of House Malos (former) Licensed bounty hunter Majority shareholder, Lorrd Engineering Owner, Stark Defense Conglomerate Civilian Medal of Honor recipient Representative, Lorrd (10 BBY-9 BBY)
|
|
| |
Bernard_Oriel | Date: Saturday, 23 Jun 2012, 7:30 AM | Message # 3 |
Colonel general
Group: Users
Messages: 803
Status: Offline
| "Any statement relating to matters significant to the application before we begin Mr Stark?"
Bernard Oriel Senator for the Planet of Vjun 1st Earl Malreaux (Second Creation) Vjun Delegation to the Imperial Senate
|
|
| |
Alyn_Stark | Date: Saturday, 23 Jun 2012, 7:46 AM | Message # 4 |
Generalissimo
Group: Users
Messages: 1359
Status: Offline
| "If you are referring to the matters on Imperial Center during the droid uprising, Senator, then I can only state that prototype designs aimed to be tested as my own personal defensive screen are not indicative of Vigilance Technologies products as a whole." Stark opened his arms, palms upwards and shrugged. "Let not a programming flaw that existed in a specific set of testbeds extend to different drone lines that have been corrected. Other than that, Senator, please proceed."
Alyn Stark Lord of Kinyov Senior Captain, Retired, Republic Navy Head of House Malos (former) Licensed bounty hunter Majority shareholder, Lorrd Engineering Owner, Stark Defense Conglomerate Civilian Medal of Honor recipient Representative, Lorrd (10 BBY-9 BBY)
|
|
| |
Bernard_Oriel | Date: Saturday, 23 Jun 2012, 7:50 AM | Message # 5 |
Colonel general
Group: Users
Messages: 803
Status: Offline
| "The Committee meant no implication that Mr Stark should speak on any given subject, rather we were offering him a chance to make an opening statement regarding the project. The Committee notes the words in the statement given.
Senator Kirkwood, you're our technological specialist; do you have an opinion on these units?"
Bernard Oriel Senator for the Planet of Vjun 1st Earl Malreaux (Second Creation) Vjun Delegation to the Imperial Senate
|
|
| |
Avram_Kirkwood | Date: Saturday, 23 Jun 2012, 3:07 PM | Message # 6 |
Lieutenant
Group: Users
Messages: 77
Status: Offline
| "Yes, Chairman Oriel," he spoke, taking a moment to drink from a glass of water. Rather than on the podium that the Committee sat or at one of the witness tables, he sat at a table off to the side, with the reporter. "If the committee members will open the holodisplays in front of them, you will be able to read my report, which I will read aloud to you."
Quote (Report for the Defense Committee on Vigilance Technologies by Senator Avram Kirkwood) The combat droid designs offered by Vigilance Technologies, based out of Lorrd, consist of six distinct models. The KSRR-001, the AS-003, the I-002, the T-009, the S-005 and the HC-001; there is no current Imperial military reporting name designated for the designs. At this time, the Defense Committee has a record of zero sales of all models; any models seen in service are in the hands of Vigilance Technologies and Mr. Stark, himself. First, I will present an overview and technical assessment of each design, followed by an assessment of the Droid Revolt incident in relation to Mr. Stark, followed by my conclusion and recommendation to the Committee.
The KSRR-001, or Kill-shot Rapid Reconnaissance series one, is a repulsorlift equipped, surface battle droid, equipped with a BlasTech RT-97C Heavy Blaster Rifle. It is capable of moving up to one-hundred-twenty-eight kilometers per hour, and lifting as high as six meters. It is equipped with a hybrid droid brain-AI hardware package, which utilized in all Vigilance Technologies droid designs. According to Vigilance Technologies, it is designed to serve in the role of infantry and marksmanship, with a reported ninety-eight percent accuracy rate that is untested by the Empire.
The AS-003, or Airstrike series three, is a surface based, aerial battle droid, designed for anti-air and anti-vehicular operations, equipped with a modified blaster cannon of unknown design and twelve micro concussion missiles, utilizing a repulsor and air cushion design similar to the KSRR-001, in addition to an ion engine to achieve flight. It has a flight ceiling of one-hundred meters, with a maximum speed of one-thousand-three-hundred kilometers per hour.
The I-002, or Interceptor series two, is a surface based, space capable, battle droid, designed for anti-fighter and planetary defense duties. It is equipped with two rotating laser canons and a rotating ion cannon, that I will concede give the design an almost unmatched rate of fire when compared to similar designs. It is outfitted with two ion engines that give it a flight speed of one-thousand-three-hundred kilometers per hour in atmosphere, and one-hundred megalights in vacuum. It is equipped with an unspecified deflector shield generator. It is reputed to have a ninety-two percent success rate against organic pilots in Clone Wars and modern era spacecraft; this is unverified by Imperial sources.
The T-009, or Thunderbold Interceptor series nine, armed with two heavy laser cannons and two variable use warhead launchers; it is designed for interception duties. Equipped with four ion engines, it is capable of a maximum speed of one-thousand-nine-hundred kilometers per hour in atmosphere, and apparently capable of even faster flight through use of its shielding through unknown means, and one-hundred-fifteen megalights in vacuum. It is also equipped with a 1.5 class hyperdrive capable of three jumps, and an unidentified deflector shield generator. In addition to the Vigilance Technologies standard droid brain, it is also fitted with a Cybot Galactica Ace-3 Droid Brain, which has been based upon the research conducted by the Separatists during the Clone Wars. Cybot Galactic was fully partnered with, in the apparent hopes of utilizing name identification to drive sales.
The S-005, or Striker Assault series five, is armed with a turreted laser cannon, an ion cannon, two dual turreted turbolaser cannons, and two three-tube warhead launchers, and is designed as a heavy assault and anti-capital ship craft. Equipped with six ion engines, it is capable of one-thousand kilometers per hour in atmosphere and one-hundred megalights in vacuum. It is equipped with a class 2 hyperdrive and unidentified deflector shield generator. It is equipped with the same hardware package as the T-009. It was designed with the intention to be utilized in unmanned anti-piracy actions.
The HC-001, or HoverCam model one, is an aerial unit, armed with a stun projector, which is intended for surveillance duties. It is capable of one-hundred kilometers per hour and has a flight ceiling of one-hundred-five meters with a repulsorlift, air cushion propulsion system. Unlike other Vigilance Technologies designs, it is equipped solely with the Cybot Galactica Ace-3 Droid Brain. It appears to be designed for use by law enforcement agencies.
At the end of the previous year, Imperial Center experienced a horrific terrorist attack which utilized a virus to turn most droids upon the population. While we know much of the details in regards to this event, we must address the fact that the applicant, and his droids, were involved in the event. Mr. Stark entered in the third hour of the crisis, in his personal YV-666, escorted by an Tri-Mark VII Interceptor, YV-929 Armed Freighter, Pursuer-class Enforcement Ship, ILH-KK Citadel-class Civilian Cruiser, Z-95 Clone Headhunter, AIAT Gunship and Rainhawk-class Transport, all modified, as well as six S-005s and twelve T-009s, all of which disembarked from Mr. Starks personal yacht, a modified C-3 Passenger Liner.
Imperial forces identified the droids, at the time engaging any droids showing signs of hostile intentions, in this case their vector indicating an attack angle. When engaged, the droids responded with lethal force. Mr. Stark claims this was a defense mechanism, however the fact remains that his designs openly engaged in combat with Imperial forces until he issued a built in killswitch that is not mentioned in any public documents in regards to his designs. It is my opinion that the presence of such a killswitch is troubling. His escort unit defied Imperial orders to ground themselves, with at least one of seven craft evading capture and imprisonment by Imperial forces.
Due to the simple fact that all designs are equipped with Artificial Intelligence, and therefore at least partially sentient, it is my opinion that these designs in question are in violation of the Responsible Sale of Drones Act. It is the AI that caused my designation of these designs as droids rather than drones. It would be a violation of Imperial law to grant an Aurek-class License to Vigilance Technologies for their designs in current form, thus I recommend a rejection of the application process.
The Honorable Avram W. Kirkwood Senator of the Cygnus Star Empire
General, Imperial Army (Ret.)
Message edited by Avram_Kirkwood - Saturday, 23 Jun 2012, 3:10 PM |
|
| |
Jame_Billingsly | Date: Sunday, 24 Jun 2012, 6:33 PM | Message # 7 |
Private
Group: Users
Messages: 1
Status: Offline
| As the committee listened to Senator Kirkwood's report, Senator Oriel would be handed a flimplast note and a datadisc, the note from Jame Billingsly, attorney at law and the house counsel for the Cambrist family, explaining that the disc contained a statement about the intent of the Responsible Sale of Drones Act that might be helpful to the committee, if it wished to enter it into the record. The statement would read as follows:
Quote (Jame_Billingsly) Chairman Oriel, members of the committee, Senator Kirkwood, I've been instructed by the author of the Responsible Sale of Drones Act to be as helpful as possible in providing you with information as to the intent of the law and its spirit. First, it should be noted that Mr. Stark is operating under a misconception about the law—Aurek-class licenses do not, in fact, apply to specific drone designs; one license is granted to one reputable company, entitling it to sell any and all drone designs (designs which must, however, be provided to the committee for review).
Because of this, it is especially important that the committee husband the Aurek-class license carefully. The Responsible Sale of Drones Act is intended to accommodate the most reputable companies, which the Empire can trust not to sell dangerous weapons to dangerous people, or to misappropriate these weapons for personal use (joyriding, etc.). If a company fails to meet these exacting standards, it is incumbent on this committee to doubt whether the company should be excepted from the committee's oversight (companies without an Aurek-class license must have their drone sales approved by the committee on a case-by-case basis).
The stakes cannot be higher—drones are an inexpensive way for actors to field large numbers of deadly starfighters, including, conceivably, questionable regimes and rogue actors on the Outer Rim that don't otherwise have the budget or infrastructure for a starfighter program. In requiring review of drone sales on a case-by-case basis, the Responsible Sale of Drones Act ensures these weapons are (as the title suggests) sold responsibly.
The facts of the droid uprising on Imperial Center are clear—Vigilance-made drones employed deadly force on Imperial starfighters. Then they exploded. Mr. Stark maintains that these drones were for his personal use, and are not representative of the market-models. Having been self-destructed rather than handed over to Imperial scrutiny, the committee will have to decide whether it's able to believe this claim, or whether the market-model designs Vigilance has provided to the committee are, in fact, the only designs in existence.
Moreover, the distinguished members of this committee must decide whether, in light of the Imperial Center incident and the fact that Vigilance Technologies remains little-known or -trusted despite its quite recent and meteoric rise to prominence, whether the company belongs in the same category as a Kuat Drive Yards or a Sienar Fleet Systems—the sort of reputable company that the Aurek-class license is meant to reward.
Thank you for your consideration and good luck in your deliberations, Senators.
Jame Billingsly Cambrist House Counsel (certainly not Hiram Brentioch)
|
|
| |
Bernard_Oriel | Date: Monday, 25 Jun 2012, 5:25 AM | Message # 8 |
Colonel general
Group: Users
Messages: 803
Status: Offline
| Mr Stark, have you any rebuttal to the words of Senator Kirkwood or Mr Billingsly?
Bernard Oriel Senator for the Planet of Vjun 1st Earl Malreaux (Second Creation) Vjun Delegation to the Imperial Senate
|
|
| |
Alyn_Stark | Date: Monday, 25 Jun 2012, 9:54 PM | Message # 9 |
Generalissimo
Group: Users
Messages: 1359
Status: Offline
| "I do, thank you, Senator Oriel.
"Firstly, Senator Kirkwood is incorrect on a point: two squadrons of Interceptor series two drones were sold to Sluis Van, Argazda, Mengjini and Alderath. Furthermore, orders for two-dozen HoverCam series one drone have been placed by Dorvalla Universal Corporation for utilization within their prison facility.
"A second point for Senator Kirkwood; flight data recordings taken from both my personal craft, as well as that of my Shadowguard, will show that my drones only engaged Imperial forces after I was fired upon. While I understand this to be a grievous error, they were acting under the testing protocol that they were currently programmed under which was to provide me with defense against any hostile threats. The utilization of the powerplant overload kill-switch in my personal prototypes existed in the event they were stolen or malfunctioned for any reason. The drones were not intended for use against Imperial forces or even, for that matter during the droid uprising. The original field test I had intended for the aforementioned prototypes was a hunting session in which I intended to seek out the person of Valin Rall, one of the Empire's most wanted Separatists and use them against his forces. The reason I gave the destruct order was to ensure that no further engagements came from the drones against Imperial forces.
"A third point for Senator Kirkwood: the artificial intelligence system you refer to as making the drones 'self aware' is nothing more than a combat learning algorithm designed to adapt to current attack patterns utilized by a foe in a given situation. The drones are not capable of independent thought or even of acting outside their mission parameters.
"To both Mr. Billingsly and Senator Kirkwood, the drone models utilized for space and ground combat with the exception of the HoverCam series one model are being fitted for options to be utilized as CUSV, or combat unmanned space vehicles. This development however is a recent addition to the current Vigilance Technologies package and in the testing phase."
Alyn Stark Lord of Kinyov Senior Captain, Retired, Republic Navy Head of House Malos (former) Licensed bounty hunter Majority shareholder, Lorrd Engineering Owner, Stark Defense Conglomerate Civilian Medal of Honor recipient Representative, Lorrd (10 BBY-9 BBY)
|
|
| |
Bernard_Oriel | Date: Sunday, 08 Jul 2012, 11:32 AM | Message # 10 |
Colonel general
Group: Users
Messages: 803
Status: Offline
| Gentlemen. Having consulted with the Defense Committee I am content to add that this application is denied - a company which has produced vessels which (under their control) fired upon the vessels of his Majesty's Imperial Navy cannot under any circumstance be entrusted with the weighty responsibility of producing vessels with the capacity to begin another "Clone War" if handed to an irresponsible world - we are unconvinced such a world would not be sold these units and might adapt such "self defense" mechanisms to their advantage, again against his Majesty's forces.
It would be undesirable to again see Droids being able to make war on Sentients. I thus in order to prevent this the Defense Committee votes against allowing these Drones. We should add that the option remains open of petitioning the Senate or Defense Committee to approve sale on a per-sale basis but we strongly encourage Vigilance Technologies to cease this project with it's strongly Separatist undertones.
Bernard Oriel Senator for the Planet of Vjun 1st Earl Malreaux (Second Creation) Vjun Delegation to the Imperial Senate
|
|
| |
LomenRyuun | Date: Sunday, 08 Jul 2012, 11:44 AM | Message # 11 |
Lieutenant general
Group: Users
Messages: 696
Status: Offline
| Having remained silent for a large portion of the proceedings and having not precisely been 'consulted' with about any of the matters, Ryuun felt compelled to speak, largely out of being left out by Oriel and feeling more than a little slighted as he did hold the position of Vice-chair of the Defense Committee.
"Chairman Oriel does have a distinct point in this matter. However, I believe it to only be fair to Vigilance Technologies, which has in part undertaken a great effort against odds and mindsets from the Clone Wars that are stacked against to make a legitimate name for itself, be granted the unlimited right and license to sell drones of the HC-001, KSRR-001 and AS-003 models as these are not a direct threat to Imperial vessels or assets to worlds that are suitable to reception.
"As Chairman Oriel mentioned, it would be very undesirable to see a repeat of the Clone Wars and the option to petition the Senate or the Defense Committee, for I see no need to require both for a sale, is one that is open."
Lomen Ryuun Senator, Doldur Sector Senator, Druckenwell Representative, Monor II (10 BBY - 9 BBY) Representative, Geridard Representative, Boranall Representative, Therenor Prime Vice-chairman, Defense Committee (Temporarily suspended) Controlling Shareholder - Druckenwell Arms Corporation
|
|
| |
Bernard_Oriel | Date: Sunday, 08 Jul 2012, 11:50 AM | Message # 12 |
Colonel general
Group: Users
Messages: 803
Status: Offline
| "Your dissenting opinion is noted and over-ruled Mr Ryuun. Carte blanche to produce any of these autonomous fighting machines is refused. Vigilance remains in possession of the option to request permission for individual sales and if the Committee is convinced of the merits of individual sales then they will be approved."
He banged his gavel, cutting off any retort. "The Defense Committee hearing is closed on this matter. We will reconvene on the next Primeday, Emergencies excepted, of which all members shall have due notice."
Bernard Oriel Senator for the Planet of Vjun 1st Earl Malreaux (Second Creation) Vjun Delegation to the Imperial Senate
|
|
| |
|